Teaching tips and suggestions for teaching the prepositions of time and place, at, on and in.
Prepositions are probably one of the trickiest areas of English grammar, and yet there is little systematic study of prepositions in major coursebooks. This could be due to three reasons:
- that prepositions are best learned along with their accompanying nouns or verbs, i.e. as part of a phrase rather than being on their own.
- that prepositions, along with other small grammatical words, are often more complicated and elusive than the 'big' structures, like verb tenses.
- that prepositions and their accompanying phrases are something that students acquire, rather than consciously learn, so there is no point focusing exclusively on a single preposition.
Whether or not any (or all) of the above is true, it is probably worth the teacher’s time to draw student’s attention to prepositions in English and help students unlock the secrets of this area.
Activity: Student-generated corpus data
Corpus data is a collection of written and spoken language stored on a computer and used for language research. Dictionary and coursebook writers use corpus data to help write material. Linguists use corpus data to find out more about how people use English. However, this data, in its raw form, is difficult for teachers to access and make use of in their classes. David Willis, and more recently Scott Thornbury, have been advocating that students create their own corpus data from texts that they have encountered in their coursebooks.
Prepositions seem like an ideal area to start when students are making their own corpus. Here are six examples of in taken from different texts in an intermediate coursebook:
Taken from Looking Forward 1 Workbook, by David Spencer, Macmillan 2002
Once students have collected several examples of the preposition in context from texts they have encountered, you can begin to analyse the segments and look for patterns. The above examples of in all describe things in relation to other things that surround them (run in trainers, in the same place, in newspapers, in the 1990s, in the role, in the field). Students should be encouraged to start a page in their notebooks where they can record examples of prepositions in this way.
Because prepositions are so overwhelmingly common, they can be found in almost any text. This often means that a well-intentioned teacher will take a text and eliminate all the prepositions, making a gap fill for students to complete. While this is not a bad exercise, its usefulness is limited if there is no effective follow-up. The danger is that the students aren’t able to correctly complete the gaps, the teacher has no satisfactory answer as to why they made mistakes and everyone is left agreeing that prepositions are very difficult.
A more measured approach would be to delete only one preposition (for example, all the instances of in or on) and explain that the gaps only need to be filled by the same word. Then concentrate on that preposition and the words that surround it.
A more difficult exercise type has also been suggested by Thornbury, in which you prepare a text and remove all the examples of the keyword you want to focus on. Students then try to put the missing word back into the text where it belongs. Here is an example:
The word at is missing from this text 7 times. Can you put it in the correct places?
He was at work, sitting quietly at his desk. She’s not here, he thought, what on earth was she playing at? At his suggestion she had promised to visit him at the end of the day, when everyone had left. But she still hadn’t come. At six o’clock I’m leaving he thought. At ten past seven he was still there.
Many of the examples in this text refer to the uses of at that were mentioned above, as well as two expressions (playing at and at his suggestion).
Activity: Illustrating in, on, at with gestures and simple diagrams
If you haven’t done so already, one logical way of explaining at, in, on is through gestures or pictures.
- For in:
Use your hands to make a circular gesture around yourself.
- For on:
Hold one hand palm upwards, tap your palm with the tips of your fingers on your other hand.
- For at:
Stand next to a chair, table or desk and point down at the desk.
Activity: Office and living room
Having students draw pictures and dictate them to each other to copy will inevitably bring up prepositions. Often prepositions of space like next to, under, and above will also come up. Here is one way of doing a picture dictation, which reviews furniture vocabulary:
- Divide the class into two groups of the same number of students, A and B.
- Tell the As that they must draw a picture of an office and include six or seven objects of office vocabulary (e.g. desk, armchair, plant, photocopier)
- Tell the Bs that they must draw a picture of a living room and include six or seven things which you typically find in a living room (e.g. television, sofa, bookcase)
- Give them a time limit to finish their drawings. Write the furniture vocabulary words up on the board for students to refer to.
- Ask each student A to work with a student B. Without showing his/her picture, A dictates to B everything that is in his/her picture while B draws. Then swap roles, with B describing and A drawing.
- Circulate and make notes of any problems they have with prepositions.
- Finally, ask them to compare their drawings. Focus on the errors that students made with the prepositions.
Activity: Hands tied
A great way to practise prepositions of space is to use actual blocks for students to use. Cuisinaire rods or Lego blocks are perfect for this. There are several ways of exploiting them. The following is a way that I used them with a secondary class in Mexico.
- Draw a simple picture of a structure that the students should reproduce with their rods or Lego.
- Give each pair of students in the class enough pieces for them to build the structure you drew a picture of.
- Ask one student from each pair to come up and look at the picture you’ve drawn. Explain that they can study the picture for only one minute.
- When they have seen the picture, ask each student to go back and sit down facing their partner.
- Tell them to put their hands behind their backs.
- The students must now describe how to make the structure to their partners, without taking their hands from behind their backs.
You can follow this up by asking them to make their own structures and explain to their partner how to make them.
You can help students remember prepositions by asking them to personalise them. Here are some activities to personalise in, at and on for time and space.
Activity: When did it happen?
Give students a copy of the following skeleton text:
An Important Event
I was at/on/in __________________ (place) when it happened. It was at ___________ (time) on ___________ (day). It was in ___________ (month), in ___________ (year). I remember that I felt ___________ (how did you feel?).
Ask them to complete the text, then read it to a partner. Can their partner guess what the event was? You can do the same text but change the title to read A frightening event/My happiest moment/My worst moment, etc.
Activity: Where's the best place to live?
Bring in a map of the city or town where you teach. Ask students to tell you where the best place to live in the city is. As students begin to tell you, elicit the following prepositional phrases: on … street, in the centre, in … neighbourhood, at the end of … street. Do the same activity with the following questions:
- Where’s the most dangerous part of the city?
- Where are the best restaurants/bars?
- What’s the most boring/ugliest part of the city?
Activity: Working times
The following questionnaire is for business students to practise the prepositions in, on, at for time. It can be easily adapted for general English.
Working times questionnaire
Answer the questions. Write a time, day, month or year. Use the correct preposition.
- When do you leave for work? _________
- When do you finish work? _________
- What days don’t you go to work? _________
- When do you get paid? _________
- When do you have your holidays? _________
- When did you last take a day off? _________
- When do you have to do your taxes? _________
- When did you start working at the place you are now? _________
- When is the busiest time of year for you at work? _________
- When is the slowest time of year for you at work? _________
Nouns and phrases
- Currently reading
Prepositions of time and place - tips and activities